Fighting to Protect Your Rights, Career & Future
Article 92 Failure To Obey Order Or Regulation in Mount Pleasant
Former Navy JAG Defense for Article 92 Allegations
An Article 92 allegation is more than a general accusation that a service member disobeyed instructions. The government must identify whether it alleges a violation of a general order or regulation, failure to obey another lawful order, or dereliction of duty. Each theory under Article 92, UCMJ, presents distinct elements and proof issues.
The Hanzel Law Firm represents service members facing Uniform Code of Military Justice investigations, Article 15 or non-judicial punishment, administrative action, and court-martial proceedings. The firm evaluates the allegation, the current procedural stage, and the potential consequences for liberty, pay, rank, discharge characterization, and military service.
Call (843) 202-4714 to discuss an Article 92 allegation with military defense counsel before responding to investigators or making a procedural decision.
Three Offenses Covered by Article 92, UCMJ
The statutory language for Article 92 Failure To Obey Order Or Regulation appears in 10 U.S.C. § 892. The current Manual for Courts-Martial provides the applicable elements, explanations, and punishment provisions for the charged offense.
Article 92 covers three distinct theories:
- Violation of a general order or regulation: Article 92(1) concerns a lawful general order or regulation that applied to the accused and was allegedly violated or disobeyed.
- Failure to obey another lawful order: Article 92(2) concerns an order issued by a member of the armed forces, the accused’s knowledge of that order, a duty to obey it, and an alleged failure to comply.
- Dereliction of duty: Article 92(3) concerns a military duty and an alleged willful or negligent failure to perform it properly.
Evidence That Can Shape the Defense
The wording and source of the order matter. Legal review may address the issuing authority, lawfulness, publication, applicability, communication, and clarity. It should also determine whether the alleged conduct violated the requirement. An unlawful order doesn’t create a lawful duty to obey, but lawfulness is a fact-specific question requiring review of the order and its surrounding circumstances.
Dereliction allegations require close examination of the claimed duty. Relevant materials may include regulations, duty descriptions, training records, counseling documents, messages, witness accounts, and evidence showing what the service member knew or reasonably should have known.
Investigations, Non-Judicial Punishment & Court-Martial
An allegation may lead to a command investigation, non-judicial punishment, administrative separation, court-martial, or overlapping proceedings. Available choices and potential consequences depend on the charged subsection, rank, prior record, command action, alleged conduct, and governing military rules.
Consulting counsel isn’t the same as providing a statement to command representatives or investigators. Article 31(b) rights generally require a suspect to receive notice of the accusation and the right to remain silent before certain questioning. The government must prove a court-martial charge beyond a reasonable doubt, while administrative and disciplinary forums may use different procedures and standards.
12 Years of Active-Duty Navy JAG Experience
Michael B. Hanzel served as both a prosecutor and defense counsel during 12 years on active duty as a U.S. Navy JAG officer. He is Article 27(b) certified for military courts and served as Senior Defense Counsel in the Navy’s largest and busiest defense litigation office. His military justice work includes Navy, Marine Corps, and Coast Guard cases at the trial and appellate levels.
The firm represents members of the Navy, Marine Corps, Army, Air Force, Coast Guard, and NOAA. It handles cases remotely and may travel when a client’s circumstances require it, allowing service members to seek representation wherever they’re stationed.
What Our work means
-
Zealous & Ethical Legal AdvocacyAfter serving on active duty, Attorney Michael Hanzel has since devoted himself to standing up for fellow servicemembers.
-
Fighting for Your Constitutional RightsAs JAG, Attorney Michael Hanzel swore an oath to protect and defend the Constitution of the United States. He will protect your rights and fighting for your freedom.
-
Know the Criminal Justice System Inside & OutOur attorneys have seen the best and worst of our justice system. They will do what it takes to navigate you through its complexities.
-
Proven Track Record as US Navy JAGWith over a decade of experience in the military justice system, Attorney Michael Hazel has achieved outstanding results for our clients.
-
Locations Served -
Case Results -
Our Blog